ACL tears are common in cutting and pivoting sports. If you play soccer, basketball, lacrosse, or ski at Bogus Basin, you probably know someone who has done it. This guide explains how we diagnose an ACL tear, what bracing can and can’t do, when surgery makes sense, and what a typical 9–12 month return-to-sport pathway looks like. You’ll also see how the plan changes when meniscus or cartilage are involved.
What the ACL does and how it tears
The anterior cruciate ligament keeps the shinbone from sliding forward and helps control rotation. Most ACL tears happen without a collision. Think of a quick plant to change direction, a sudden stop, or a misstep while landing. Many patients feel or hear a “pop,” then notice swelling within a few hours and a sense that the knee is unstable.
First steps after the injury
Early on, the goals are simple: calm swelling, restore gentle motion, and keep the quadriceps working. Ice, compression, elevation, and short-term crutch use help. A hinged brace can protect the knee while you regain control. We usually order X-rays to rule out fracture and an MRI if the exam points to ligament or meniscus damage.
Quick rule of thumb: if your knee swelled soon after the injury and feels like it might give way, get checked. Earlier clarity saves time later.
Bracing: when it helps and when it doesn’t
A good brace can protect a wobbly knee for day-to-day life and early rehab. It can also reduce your fear of moving. What it can’t do is heal a torn ACL or reliably prevent giving-way episodes during cutting and pivoting. If your daily life is light and you avoid high-risk moves, bracing plus therapy may get you back to comfortable activity. If you want to cut, pivot, or play field and court sports, surgery often becomes the practical choice.
“Prehab” before surgery
Strong legs and good motion make recovery smoother. We aim for:
- Swelling under control
- Full extension and near-normal flexion
- A firing quadriceps (you should be able to straighten the knee and do gentle straight-leg raises)
Many patients do two to four weeks of focused prehab before surgery. If the knee is stiff at the time of surgery, it’s more likely to be stiff afterward.
Surgery options: how we rebuild the ACL
ACLs are reconstructed rather than stitched together. The torn ligament is replaced with a graft, then the graft heals into bone and remodels into a new ligament over time. Common choices:
- Patellar tendon (BTB) autograft. Strong fixation, often preferred for younger athletes in pivoting sports. Some patients notice kneeling pain early on.
- Hamstring tendon autograft. Popular option with a small harvest site. Fixation methods vary; rehab focuses on regaining hamstring strength.
- Quadriceps tendon autograft. Gaining popularity for its size and strength. Useful in revisions and primary cases.
- Allograft (donor tissue). Helpful for some adults, multi-ligament injuries, or revisions. Many surgeons avoid allograft in teens and young competitive athletes because of higher failure rates in that group.
The “best” graft balances sport demands, age, anatomy, and personal preference. We’ll lay out the trade-offs so the choice is clear.
What if the meniscus or cartilage are injured too?
- Meniscus repair (stitches) protects joint health and often extends weight-bearing and motion restrictions early on. Plan for a measured ramp-up.
- Meniscus trim (partial meniscectomy) usually allows a quicker early rehab, though long-term we try to preserve as much meniscus as possible.
- Cartilage procedures may shift milestones. We’ll explain how they affect weight-bearing and return-to-running.
What recovery really looks like (typical ranges)
Everyone heals at a slightly different pace. Your sport, graft choice, and associated procedures all matter. Here’s a practical frame you can plan around:
Weeks 0–2
- Calm the knee. Control swelling.
- Achieve full extension and safe early flexion.
- Gentle quad work, patellar mobility, and careful gait training.
- Brace and crutches as advised.
Weeks 2–6
- Normalize walking.
- Build range and early strength with a focus on quads, hips, and core.
- Stationary bike often enters here.
- If a meniscus was repaired, follow specific flexion and weight-bearing limits.
6–12 weeks
- Progress strengthening.
- Begin low-impact conditioning.
- Balance and control work to reduce re-injury risk.
3–6 months
- Introduce running once strength, control, and impact tolerance are ready.
- Add change-of-direction drills later in this window if testing supports it.
9–12 months
- Most athletes return to cutting and pivoting sports during this window if they pass strength, hop, and movement-quality testing.
- Some sports or multi-procedure cases need more time. Passing criteria is safer than chasing a date.
Return-to-sport is criteria-based, not calendar-based
We don’t “guess” you’re ready. We test it. That includes quadriceps and hamstring strength, hop tests, movement-quality screens, and sometimes return-to-sport assessments that look at symmetry and control under fatigue. Meeting criteria lowers the chance of re-injury and helps you feel confident when you step back onto the field.
Should I wear a brace when I go back?
Some athletes like the reassurance of a functional brace for the first season back. Others prefer to skip it once they pass testing. A brace can help confidence, but it isn’t a shield. Strong legs, good mechanics, and a smart workload plan protect you more than any strap or hinge.
How to lower the risk of a second ACL injury
- Finish your rehab and meet all return-to-sport criteria.
- Use a neuromuscular injury-prevention program two to three times a week in season.
- Watch game and practice loads. Big spikes raise risk.
- Sleep and nutrition support healing and performance more than most people think.
Adults vs teens: what changes?
Teens and college-age athletes face higher re-tear rates, especially in pivoting sports. We talk openly about graft choice, strength targets, and prevention programs. In growing athletes, we use techniques that protect the growth plates while still restoring stability.
When non-operative care is reasonable
If your sport or job rarely involves cutting and pivoting, or if your knee feels stable for the activities you love, you may choose rehab alone. Many cyclists, hikers, and gym-goers do well without reconstruction. If the knee keeps giving way or you want to compete in pivoting sports, surgery becomes the more durable path.
A quick story from clinic
A 17-year-old winger planted to cut inside and felt a pop. Her knee ballooned that night. Exam and MRI confirmed an ACL tear with a small lateral meniscus tear suitable for repair. Her goal was to play college soccer. We set expectations early: prehab to get motion back, then ACL reconstruction with meniscus repair, followed by a staged rehab. She learned the milestones up front, from sling-free walking to first jogs to controlled cutting. She passed return-to-sport testing at 10 months and eased into competition with a workload plan that kept her fresh. The clarity of that plan mattered as much as the surgery.
Why patients choose Catalyst for ACL care
- Fellowship-trained orthopaedic sports medicine surgeons
- A team that coordinates imaging, surgery, and rehab so you are never guessing
- Clear, criteria-based return-to-sport testing and prevention guidance
- Local care in Boise and the Treasure Valley with experience across youth, collegiate, and adult athletes
Request an Appointment
Complete our appointment form and we’ll get back to you with available dates and times.
Please note that this form is not HIPAA compliant, if you are concerned about security and would like to request an appointment in the most secure way please call the scheduling office directly. Please do not include any personal health information in this form.
Learn more from our surgeons:
FAQs
How long until I’m back to sport after ACL surgery?
Most athletes return in 9–12 months once they pass strength and movement testing. Multi-procedure cases or contact sports can take longer.
Will I need a brace after surgery?
Some athletes use one for confidence the first season back. It’s optional. Strong legs, good mechanics, and smart workload matter more.
Which graft is best?
There isn’t a single “best.” We choose between patellar tendon, hamstring, quadriceps, and sometimes allograft based on sport, age, anatomy, and goals.
Can I avoid surgery?
Yes, if your activities don’t demand cutting and pivoting and your knee feels stable with rehab. If the knee gives way or you want to play field and court sports, surgery is usually the better answer.
What increases the risk of a second ACL tear?
Returning too early, strength deficits, poor mechanics, sudden workload spikes, and inadequate prevention work. Criteria-based testing and a prevention program lower the risk.